Follow Up: Comcast Dropped Signals

PROBLEM:

Starting late Thursday, March 26, errors began to occur on DACT systems, not only on calls primarily originating from Comcast network customers but also other originator’s networks. These errors started to increase exponentially. The calls were coming from multiple regions across North America. All DACT formats were impacted during this episode. When actually measuring the timing of Contact ID DTMF signals, it appeared the inter-digit spacing was increased to as much as 70 milliseconds. With other formats there appeared to be echo and waveform distortion. Typically in VoIP systems, this is usually indicative of either poor network performance or the use of other than G711 CODEC.

This problem occurred before signals were handed off to affected central stations, so there was little any central station could have done to mitigate this problem, even if it is served by multiple carriers.

Many central stations were overwhelmed with the numbers of calls as panels tried to communicate, then redialing up to 16 times. This has the additional effect of reducing available capacity on incoming lines for other than Comcast customer panels.

THE WAY PSTN NETWORK WORKS TODAY:

Virtually all calls these days are transported by VoIP, somewhere along the way, even if the customer’s panel is connected to a legacy PSTN.

Regarding the issue at hand, this diagram shows how these signals are transported from a customer’s panel beginning with the Comcast network, then ultimately to the central station.

Carrier+Routing+Comcast2

In this instance Comcast calls that were originated from Comcast customers traveled though the Comcast network but are then handed off to an interexchange carrier.  In this case the interexchange carrier was Peerless Networks. Since Comcast uses multiple vendors for this traffic, some Comcast calls would be effected, others would not.  A very high percentage of the calls routed through Peerless seemed to fail.

WHAT WAS DONE:

Several of the national monitoring/alarm companies contacted Comcast at a high level on March 30, and by the morning of March 31 Comcast was able to move the traffic away from Peerless. This, for the most part, slowed down the error rate to manageable levels. Central stations may still be receiving communication troubles messages and other signals as communications start to restore.

NOW WHAT:

We are continuing to follow this issue. AICC has started a project to work with the carriers. But what we really need is evidence. So that we effectively move forward, please complete the AICC DACT Dropped Call Survey.

American Alarm Makes First ASAP Dispatch in New England

On March 22, 2015 at 7:06 p.m., a motion sensor alarm was received from an American Alarm and Communications customer in Richmond, VA. Upon call verification, American Alarm Central Station Operator Bob Goulet used the Automated Secure Alarm Protocol (ASAP) to contact Richmond police and transfer information to the Richmond PSAP. It was the first ASAP dispatch made from a central station in New England.

“After working hard with the CSAA to implement ASAP, we were very excited to put the system into live action,” said Chris Newhook, Central Station Manager at American Alarm. “Our team is trained and ready to react. Bob did an excellent job.”

The alarm came from the Richmond location of a multi-state retail operation headquartered in Massachusetts. American Alarm operates its own dedicated Five Diamond Central Station  and now has ASAP capability in Richmond, Washington D.C. and Tempe, AZ. American Alarm and the CSAA are now working with the City of Boston to implement ASAP as part of the city’s ongoing dispatch center upgrade.

Find out more about ASAP.

Security Incentive Bob Goulet, left, receives a $50 gift card from American Alarm CFO Louis Sampson for making the first dispatch using ASAP.

Central station operator Bob Goulet, left, receives a $50 gift card from American Alarm CFO Louis Sampson for making the first dispatch using ASAP.

Jay Hauhn is New Executive Director of CSAA International

Industry Veteran Tapped to Lead Association Representing Professional Monitoring Companies

VIENNA, VA (March 31, 2015) – Jay Hauhn, a 38-year veteran of the security industry, is the new executive director of CSAA International. Hauhn will assume his new role, which is the lead staff position of the association, on April 6.

“Jay brings a unique combination of strength in technology, existing relationships with public safety liaisons and sister associations, knowledge of new players in the market, and an understanding of the values and goals of the association,” said CSAA First Vice President Pam Petrow. “With his leadership, CSAA will be able to engage our members and collaborators in new ways to keep us relevant and stronger than ever.”

Jay Hauhn headshot 2013

Jay Hauhn

“I am excited to have the chance to lead CSAA, and to work with the board of directors, the volunteer committees and the staff, particularly at this time when rapidly-changing technology impacts our industry like never before,” said Hauhn, who has close ties with CSAA, having served as president of the association since October 2013.

“I started my career in the security industry working in a central station, and it’s a remarkable opportunity to cap off my career as the executive director of the association that represents monitoring companies and protects their interests,” he continued.

Hauhn recently retired as chief technology officer and vice president of industry relations at Tyco Integrated Security, where he was responsible for product technology and innovation along with industry and government relations. He led product and service solution development and engineering as well as development and implementation of product strategy. He was also responsible for interaction with industry associations, regulatory agencies and local, state and federal governments.

Previously, Hauhn served as chairman of the Security Industry Association (SIA) and currently sits on the board of directors of the Security Industry Alarm Coalition (SIAC). He is the recipient of numerous industry awards, including SIA’s “Statesman Award” in 2009 and SIAC’s William Mooney award in 2011. In April 2011, he was inducted into the Security Industry Hall of Fame. Hauhn was also recognized as one of the “Security Industry’s Most Influential People” in 2012 and named one of the forty “Most influential People in Security & Fire” by IFSEC (International Fire and Security Exhibition and Conference) in 2013.

As CSAA executive director, Hauhn will follow Steve Doyle, who retired in September 2014, and Louis T. Fiore, a CSAA past president, who filled the executive position while the CSAA board conducted its search. “The members of the CSAA board would like to thank Lou Fiore for taking on the responsibilities of interim executive director,” said Petrow.  “Lou, a distinguished industry veteran, has ably filled the executive role by leading the staff and sustaining our relationships with members and partner associations, in addition to maintaining his leadership roles with the Alarm Industry Communications Committee and the Standards Committee.”

For more information, contact Elizabeth Lasko at CSAA, 703-242-4670 x 16 or ewlasko@csaaintl.org.

About CSAA International

The Central Station Alarm Association International (CSAA) is an internationally-recognized non-profit trade association that represents professional monitoring companies that are listed by a CSAA-approved Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratory, such as FM Global, Intertek/ETL or UL. CSAA is legally entitled to represent its members before Congress and regulatory agencies on the local, state and federal levels, and other authorities having jurisdiction (AHJs) over the industry. Since its incorporation in 1950, CSAA has served its members’ interests through education, online training, meetings and conventions, certification, insurance, and industry standards. www.csaaintl.org. For more information, contact Elizabeth Lasko at CSAA, 703-242-4670 x 16.

Breaking: Issue with Receiving Alarm Signals via Comcast

From AICC Chair Lou Fiore:

“We have received word of central stations complaining of issues receiving alarm signals since Friday, March 24. It turns out that the majority of the issues have Comcast as the originating carrier. The issue seems widespread from Massachusetts to Texas at the moment and may be spreading beyond. The majority of the issues are with the Contact ID format. It appears that the DTMF tones and the spaces between them are being lengthened.

“I have reached out to our contact at Comcast. They are aware of the problem, know the cause and are in the process of resolving it — hopefully within hours.

“I urge all affected central stations to fill out the AICC DACT survey so that we can track this issue and other similar issues.”

— March 31, 2015

Complete the AICC DACT Survey

CSAA Releases Results of Survey of Central Station Monitoring Companies’ Wage and Salary Practices

CSAA International has released the results of the 2013 Wage and Salary Survey, which will assist businesses within the industry with competitive compensation practices. The survey is the most extensive snapshot of industry practices to date.

The purpose of the survey is to assist monitoring companies with hiring and compensation decisions.  “The information gathered will be very useful to central station companies looking to impro2014-WageSalaryPractices-Iconve or expand their businesses,” said CSAA Past President Bud Wulforst, who was instrumental in the development of the survey. “If, for instance, you are a national monitoring company, how do you know what is a fair and competitive wage in Missouri vs. California? And what if you are only monitoring video, as opposed to fire, burglary, PERS, temperature, or other monitoring outlets? This survey will help get you that data.”

The data will be particularly useful to the human resources staff at alarm companies.

The survey collected information from the year 2013 in the following areas:

  • Demographic Data
  • Types of Monitoring
  • Executive & Operational Management
  • Central Station, Office, Sales, and Marketing Positions
  • Dealer & Customer Support, Data
  • IT & Telecom Services
  • Benefits Packages
  • Position Descriptions

Confidential participation was open to all monitoring companies—both CSAA members and non-members. The survey was created by the CSAA Contract Council and was facilitated by Barnes Associates, an advisory and consulting firm that specializes in the security alarm industry.

“This survey is an example of CSAA volunteers working to create resources that will be invaluable to all our members,” said CSAA President Jay Hauhn. “We especially thank the leadership of the Contract Monitoring Council for the efforts they made to gather the content. And a very special thank you goes to Barnes Associates for the extraordinary work they did to assemble the data in such a user-friendly format.”

To purchase the survey results, visit http://csaaintl.org/csaa-wage-salary-survey/ .

Additional resource: the Security Industry Recruitment Center is the premiere online recruiting resource for the electronic security industry. Post your open positions today!

Alarm Industry Seeks Answers in the Issue of Dropped Signals

The Alarm Industry Communications Committee (AICC) has launched an industry-wide survey on the issue of dropped signals involving Digital Alarm Communications Transmitters (DACT). The survey aims to collect information on how the telecom network’s move towards Internet Protocol (IP) affects these signals.

The survey is open to all central stations in the industry. Results of this research initiative will be reported on at the June 2015 AICC meeting. For more information, visit http://csaaintl.org/dact-dropped-signals-survey/.

CSAA 365: Security Industry Recruiting Center

Got a minute to spare? Take a quick break to view our new “CSAA 365” video. It’s the latest in our series of videos that we hope will help our members take advantage of CSAA’s services and member benefits all year long.

[youtube=http://youtu.be/HZfQCXM5OHE]

In future videos you’ll hear from CSAA leaders, volunteers, and staff about many more CSAA programs and activities. As always, thank you for your membership and support.

(Missed the introductory video? Check it out at http://youtu.be/0Kl7_8nZ7Hw or just scroll down the blog to find it.)

Teresa Gonzalez Appointed to CSAA Board of Directors

Teresa Gonzalez, president of United Central Control, Inc. (San Antonio, TX) has been appointed to the CSAA Board of Directors.

“No association can succeed without volunteer participation, and Teresa has been one of our most active and effective member volunteers,” said CSAA President Jay Hauhn. “The leadership she has demonstrated as co-chair of our Education Committee since 2012 has resulted in significant upgrades to our educational programs. I am excited that she will be bringing this leadership and dedication to the CSAA Board.”

“It is a privilege and an honor to be asked to participate as a board member for CSAA. The association is a driving force in the industry representing its members in important initiatives effecting our industry,” said Gonzalez. “The security industry is experiencing rapid change more than ever in our history. Our association must also change to continue to be relevant and provide continued value to its members. It takes a lot of work, commitment and courage to make changes. CSAA is at a pivotal point of change, and it’s exciting to be a part of that change.”

Teresa Gonzalez (photo courtesy of Teresa Gonzalez)

Teresa Gonzalez (photo courtesy of Teresa Gonzalez)

Ms. Gonzalez is a 35-year security industry professional with over 28 of those years managing personnel, business operations and technical advancements in the central station environment. She joined United Central Control, Inc. (UCC) in 1997 as the Assistant Operations Manager where she was responsible for all technical and operational aspects of the company. In 2004 she was promoted to General Manager and in 2005 to Vice President.  In 2008 Gonzalez was promoted to the position of President, and appointed to the UCC Board of Directors in 2014.

“I look forward to working more closely with President Hauhn and the great group of successful business owners, executives and advisors who are on the CSAA board today,” said Gonzalez. “Learning from their experience and knowledge will be an added bonus.”

–Elizabeth Lasko, CSAA

AICC Takes to the Hill to Talk #NetNeutrality

The week of February 9 has been a busy one for the alarm industry in responding to the FCC’s announcements regarding net neutrality.

AICC Chair (and CSAA Executive Director) Lou Fiore, along with AICC lobbyist Bill Signer, CSAA counsel Ben Dickens, and CSAA counsel Mary Sisak, visited the offices of more than a dozen Members of Congress to raise awareness of the concerns the alarm industry on this topic.

AICC’s message to legislators is that alarm industry companies welcome competition on a level playing field, but is concerned that when broadband and wireless providers offer the same alarm and video monitoring services, fair competition will not exist without some safeguards.

Rep. Bob Latta (R-CO) and AICC Chair Lou Fiore

Rep. Bob Latta (R-OH) and AICC Chair Lou Fiore

Fiore explains, “As broadband and wireless providers enter the business, we are concerned that they could use their control of the network to gain an unfair competitive advantage. If these companies do so, our customers will be at risk — and small companies, such as those that make up more than 60% of our industry, could be driven out of business.”

In 1996, recognizing that the alarm industry would be vulnerable to anti-competitive practices by a service provider engaged in alarm monitoring, Congress enacted Section 275 as part of the Telecommunication Act. Section 275 requires a carrier engaged in alarm monitoring to:

  • provide alarm companies with the same services they provide their affiliates on a nondiscriminatory basis
  • not engage in cross subsidization
  • not use alarm company customer data to market their own alarm services

Section 275 also provides for an expedited complaint process at the FCC, an issue critical for small businesses.

The AICC is asking legislators to include these safeguards in any discussion of net neutrality or Telecommunications Act rewrite.

Fiore explained that AICC’s message to legislators is that of an industry, comprised mainly of small businesses, that is crucial to public safety. “Alarm companies are critical to ensuring that emergency services are deployed promptly and appropriately,” he said.

Much more on this issue in the coming weeks.

–Elizabeth Lasko, CSAA staff, 2/12/15

ASIS Foundation — Secure Your Future Scholarship

Security practitioners or those who aspire to a career in this field may apply for the ASIS Foundation/University of Phoenix full-tuition scholarships. Professionals may apply to earn either an undergraduate or graduate degree at a University of Phoenix on-ground campus or may attend University of Phoenix online.

  • Open Application: February 2, 2015
  • Application deadline: April 6, 2015
  • Scholarship award date: June 16, 2015

More information and apply now.